Prestige breeds
Wagyu:
fat as flavour.
Few words are used as generously on menus. What wagyu actually denotes, why A5 does not automatically taste better, what sets Kobe apart from everything else — and how to cook very fatty beef without wasting it.
Four breeds
"Wagyu" literally means Japanese cattle and covers four breeds. Roughly nine in ten animals are Japanese Black — the breed that produces the extreme marbling.
The scale
The Beef Marbling Standard measures fat distribution alone. From BMS 8 the meat reaches quality grade 5 — but the scale does not stop there.
One origin
Kobe is not a breed but a protected brand for Tajima cattle from Hyōgo Prefecture that meet precisely defined criteria.
What wagyu denotes
Wagyu is an umbrella term for four Japanese cattle breeds: Japanese Black (Kuroge Washu), Japanese Brown, Japanese Shorthorn and Japanese Polled. About 90 per cent of Japan's fattening herd is Japanese Black — the breed whose animals store fat not only under the skin but deep inside the muscle.
That intramuscular fat melts considerably earlier than ordinary beef fat: depending on the animal, its melting point sits between 25 and 30 °C, sometimes lower — below body temperature, in other words. Hence the impression that the meat dissolves in the mouth. It is less a question of tenderness than of fat that is already liquid before you chew.
Japanese grading
Every Japanese carcass side receives two marks: a letter for meat yield and a figure for quality.
| Part of the grade | Scale | What is assessed |
|---|---|---|
| Yield | A, B, C | Share of usable meat in the carcass. A is above average. |
| Quality | 1 to 5 | Four criteria: marbling, meat colour and brightness, firmness and texture, colour and quality of the fat. The lowest of the four decides. |
| Marbling (BMS) | 1 to 12 | A finer scale within the quality grade. BMS 8 to 12 corresponds to quality grade 5. |
"A5" therefore means: top yield class, top quality class. It says nothing about the breed, nothing about how long the animal was fattened and nothing about whether the cut suits what you plan to do with it. An A5 at BMS 12 is so fatty that 100 grams is a full portion for most people.
Kobe: the tightest rules
Kobe beef is not a quality verdict but a registered trademark. The awarding body in Hyōgo requires an animal to meet all of the following:
- Tajima lineage of the Japanese Black, born and raised in Hyōgo Prefecture.
- Slaughtered in Hyōgo.
- A bullock or a female that has not yet calved.
- Marbling of BMS 6 or higher.
- Yield grade A or B.
- Carcass weight below 500 kilograms.
Only a few thousand animals a year meet these criteria. Genuine Kobe is correspondingly rare outside Japan; in Europe a limited number of approved establishments supply the market, and every certified piece carries a ten-digit identification number along with the seal bearing the Japanese character for Kobe.
Wagyu outside Japan
Since Japanese genetics were exported in the 1990s, wagyu has been bred in Australia, the United States, South America and Europe. Mostly these are crosses:
- Fullblood: one hundred per cent wagyu genetics, documented without gaps.
- Purebred: brought above 93 per cent by repeated backcrossing.
- F1 cross: wagyu by angus or holstein, the commonest case in the trade. Much less marbling than Japanese fullblood, but affordable and often better suited to a normal steak.
Australia uses its own scale from 0 to 9+, which does not map onto BMS even though the numbers look similar. An Australian "marble score 9" sits roughly in the BMS 9 to 11 range, but the assessment follows a different method.
How to cook it
Almost none of the rules for an ordinary steak apply here.
- Slice thin. With high marbling, one to one and a half centimetres is right, not four. A thick A5 steak is unpleasantly rich for most people.
- No oil, no added fat. The meat brings more of it than the pan can hold. Dry hot pan, meat in, spoon off the rendered fat.
- Briefly. Forty-five to ninety seconds a side is enough. Aim for medium rare; too cool and the fat stays firm, too hot and it runs out entirely.
- Little salt, nothing else. Flaky salt after searing. Sauces, herb butter and pepper crusts make no sense here.
- Small portion. Eighty to 120 grams a head at high marbling, served sliced into strips. As a main course, put something acidic alongside — pickled vegetables, daikon, a splash of ponzu.
Watch out for these phrases
"Wagyu burger", "wagyu style", "Kobe-style beef" and "Kobe burger" are not protected terms in Europe. A patty from an F1 cross is perfectly legitimate, but it has little to do with Japanese A5. If you want to know for certain, ask for country of origin, wagyu percentage and grade — a house serving real wagyu can give you all three.
Is it worth it?
As an experience, yes; as everyday eating, no. If you want to know once what BMS 10 tastes like, order it in a restaurant as a small starter — that costs a fraction of a whole steak and answers the question. For regular enjoyment, well-aged beef of a European breed is usually the better choice: more beef flavour, less fat, and you can eat a normal portion without it becoming too much.
Read next
Which breed brings which flavour?
Charolais, Limousin, Angus, Galloway, Simmental — and which of them actually graze in Luxembourg.